Reliability of ranking of three generations of test tube babies in China
With the progress of science and technology and the increasing demand for fertility, IVF technology has been widely used and developed in China. Many couples are confused about which hospital to choose for the third-generation IVF surgery. They hope to make decisions by referring to the ranking. However, it is still worth discussing whether the ranking list of the three generations of IVF in China is reliable.
Sources and problems of the list
At present, some domestic authoritative organizations of gynecology and obstetrics and the related associations of baby test tubes have released the ranking list of third-generation test tube babies. These lists are mainly based on the hospital's reproductive counseling service quality, surgical success rate, patient satisfaction and other indicators for evaluation. However, the reliability of the list is questionable because there is no unified standard for the evaluation of the list, and there are disputes about whether the evaluation process is fair and transparent.
First, how to evaluate the quality of reproductive counseling service in a hospital is a complex problem. The service level and standards of different hospitals are different. Without clear measurement indicators, objectivity is difficult to guarantee. Secondly, the success rate of surgery is a controversial indicator. The success rate is affected by many factors, such as etiology, age, physique, etc. It is difficult for patients who perform three generations of IVF operations in the same hospital to be completely consistent, so the assessment of the success rate is also subjective. Third, patient satisfaction is also an indicator that is difficult to evaluate objectively. Different patients have different satisfaction with services.
In addition, the source of the list also needs to be considered. Some of the lists may be pushed by hospitals or relevant institutions, which have interests, and the evaluation results may be manipulated to some extent. Therefore, we need to be cautious about the reliability of the list.
Reference indicators for selecting hospitals
If we cannot fully trust the reliability of the list, we can consider the reference indicators for selecting hospitals from the following aspects.
First, the qualification and reputation of the hospital is an important consideration. Select a specialized obstetrics and gynecology hospital or an authoritative baby test tube institution, such as Peking Union Medical College Hospital, Shanghai Changhai Hospital, etc. These hospitals generally have a high level of technology and rich clinical experience, and can provide more professional services.
Secondly, we can judge the strength of the hospital from its equipment and technical strength. Advanced equipment can provide more accurate diagnosis and surgical operation. The strong technical force indicates that the hospital has a high level of technology.
In addition, we can consider consulting other patients who have successfully undergone three generations of IVF surgery for their opinions and experience. They can share the real situation and personal feelings of the hospital for reference.
Summary
At present, the reliability of the ranking list of third-generation IVF infants in China remains to be discussed. Due to the lack of unified standards for evaluation, there are disputes about whether the evaluation process is fair and transparent, and the reliability of the list has some problems. When selecting hospitals, we can refer to the hospital's qualifications and reputation, equipment and technical strength, as well as the opinions and experience of other patients. Taking these factors into account, we can more accurately choose the hospital that suits us. It is hoped that an authoritative and reliable ranking system can be introduced in China in the future to provide better reference for patients.
